Sunday, September 17, 2023

The NASA Report: A Personal Commentary

 

NASA released its report on UFOs, I mean UAP, on Thursday, September 14, 2023, and to my way of thinking it was just more of the same. Ever since Congress demanded some sort of response after NAVY cockpit videos were leaked, there have been hearings, mandates, investigations and reports, and basically, nothing new has come out of any of it. It is almost like we’re still living in the twentieth century. 

The May 2023 NASA UAP Panel press conference.


You can read the whole NASA report here:

https://www.nasa.gov/sites/default/files/atoms/files/uap_independent_study_team_-_final_report_0.pdf

Peer Review and the Scientific Method

For those of us on the other side of the fence, meaning, simply, we had hoped that rather than a report outlining, once again strategies for gathering data, we would have something more concrete. Instead, on page 25, we are told:

To date, in the peer-reviewed scientific literature, there is no conclusive evidence suggesting an extraterrestrial origin for UAP. When it comes to UAP, the challenge we have is that the data needed to explain these anomalous sightings often do not exist; this includes eyewitness reports, which on their own can be interesting and compelling, but aren’t reproducible and usually lack the information needed to make any definitive conclusions about a phenomenon’s provenance.

What I found interesting was the reference to “peer-reviewed scientific literature.” That limits their search parameters to a specific source overlooking the body of information that was collected for decades by military personnel who provided some very compelling evidence in the form of eyewitness testimony, electronic gathered data and some interesting gun camera films.

For a moment, let me digress. Throughout the report, they referred to metadata, as opposed, I guess to other types of data. What that meant was that with most UFO sightings, there were incomplete times, or locations, directions, weather, or other sorts of information that would be valuable in identifying the UFO. Without these sorts of data, then a solution, though mundane, might be impossible to achieve.

There is, however, a long-term investigation in which these sorts of metadata had been collected and I’m thinking of the Project Blue Book files. True, many cases contained gaps in the metadata but that was more the result of poor investigative techniques by those involved than anything nefarious. The data were there had they bothered to gather them at the time of their investigation.

In other cases, there was an abundance of all sorts of data. As but a single example, I’m thinking of the Washington National sightings of July 1952. There was eyewitness testimony from military and commercial airline pilots. There were observers on the ground both military and civilian, and many of them independent of one another. There were radar sightings on multiple radars on various airfields, and there were eyewitness observations of the objects painted by radar by both pilots and observers on the ground.

I believe that all the data needed for a comprehensive study of those sightings is still available in the Project Blue Book files, though the opinions of those who investigated the case in 1952 are certainly biased toward finding terrestrial solutions. There are statements from the eyewitnesses collected in the hours after the events, there are newspaper reports (and yes, I get that the press can be somewhat credulous in their reporting), weather data available, locations are well known, and there are star charts that provide data about the bright stars, planets and other astronomical phenomena. This would, I suspect, provide some very compelling evidence, if it was examined in a dispassionate fashion.

I had hoped when we finally saw the NASA report, there would be a section that dealt with the historical perspective. I know they couldn’t possibly look at all twelve thousand sightings data the Air Force had gathered, but I had hoped that they would look at some of the more interesting sightings where there is an abundance of data gathered at the time of the sighting.

THE SCIENTIFIC METHOD

Instead, we were treated to a lecture on the scientific method and how science is supposed to work. They tell us:

The scientific method challenges us to solve problems by stringently evaluating our own ideas, by being willing to be wrong, and by following the data into unknown territory – wherever it may lead us. As Carl Sagan wrote in The Demon-Haunted World, “science carries us toward an understanding of how the world is, rather than how we would wish it to be.”

Which is a great philosophy, but in my experience in the world of UFOs, the attitude was often is it cannot be therefore it is not. Later in the report, they wrote:

In science, data need to be reproducible, and hypotheses falsifiable – the scientific method works by systematically analyzing data with the intent to falsify the hypothesis. As a general principal, the data should support measurement that can rule out specific explanations or interpretations, leaving us with no choice but to embrace its opposite. In the case of the UAP, the hypothesis we seek to reject (or “null hypothesis”) is that the UAP have phenomenology consistent with known or technological causes. Eyewitness reports should be considered along with corroborating sensor data in the study of UAP as reports may reveal patterns (for example, clusters in time or location). Yet, without calibrated sensor data to accompany it, no report can provide conclusive evidence of UAP or enable a study into the details of what was witnessed. While witnesses may be inherently credible, reports are not repeatable by others, and they do not allow a complete investigation into the possible cognitive biases and errors (such as accuracy in perception, or misperception caused by environmental factors the recording device, judgment or misjudgment of distance and speed, for example). Therefore, reports do not alone constitute data that can support a repeatable, reproducible analysis, and the hypothesis that what was witnessed was a manifestation of known natural or technological phenomena cannot be falsified.

Which seems to be a way to reject testimony that is not accompanied by something more tangible than just the tale told by the witnesses. Sensor data and radar tracks would add some of that additional data, though this too is subject to bias and interpretation by the investigators. I suppose I should point out that we have examples of the bias based on the past investigations including Project Blue Book and the University of Colorado study, known as the Condon Committee. The Hippler letter is an example of this bias and you can learn more about it here:

http://kevinrandle.blogspot.com/2007/03/hippler-letter.html

http://kevinrandle.blogspot.com/2022/11/the-latest-on-government-uap-report.html

They are using the scientific method to reject the witness testimony because the observations are not repeatable. This too, might be inaccurate. The first thing would be a UFO flap, which is concentrated area of UFO sightings. There might be dozens of sightings over a short period of hours or days in a limited area. It could be possible to send in a team while the flap is ongoing. They could gather additional testimony, but they could also bring in the instruments to gather the sensor data, and cameras to underscore the value of all that testimony. Not exactly repeatability, but then meteor falls and lightning, as but two examples, are fleeting phenomena and are unpredictable. Given the proper circumstances and a “go team” might provide the opportunity for proper scientific observation.

This, of course, doesn’t consider landing trace cases or events in which the UFO interacts with the environment. The Levelland sightings of November 2, 1957, had they been investigated properly at the time, might have provided the information that could have falsified the null hypothesis. There would have been material to take into a lab for analysis and effects that might have been detectable. If a car was stalled by a strong electromagnetic field, then that field might have changed the magnetic signature of the car. Scientists with the Condon Committee actually proposed a way detect those changes, but did not bother to follow up on the theory. They thought it would be difficult if not impossible to find the cars that had been involved after more than a decade.

There is one more aspect to this that should be mentioned. Fran Ridge and his team has created a network of sites that have equipment designed to pick up anomalies in the area. There is a spectrum of anomalies that these node centers collect that would provide the metadata that NASA requires. The important point here is that often the UAP sighting is independent of the detection at the node center. Once there is an alert in one of the centers, they then search various databases looking for a matching UAP sighting. This does bring an element of instrumentality into the investigations and provides multiple chains of evidence that can be accessed. Ridge has said they are attempting to add a photographic component to these centers. A sighting that triggers the sensors and in which photographs or videos were captured would provide some very persuasive evidence, especially if there were photos taken by multiple, independent sources and coupled to the MADAR data.

AARO AND THE INVESTIGATION OF REPORTS

Here’s another aspect of the report that I found a bit disturbing. According to the NASA report:

Recently, the DoD began encouraging military aviators to disclose anomalies they encountered which resulted in a significant increase in UAP reports: Between March 5, 2021, and August 30, 2022, DoD received a total of 247 new UAP reports, according to an analysis published by the Office of the Director of National Intelligence (ODNI) in 2022. In contrast, 263 reports had been filed in the 17 years prior to March 2021. Dr. Sean Kirkpatrick reported at this panel’s public meeting that AARO has now collected more than 800 reported events. This includes the addition of data from the FAA. ARRO and ODNI assess that the observed increase in the reporting rate due to a better understanding of the possible threats that UAP may represent – either as flight safety hazard or as potential adversity collection platforms.

This is somewhat interesting for two reasons. First, they provide a new number for reports received.  We have moved beyond the early number of 144 that the initial report provided and learn they have more than 800.

But second, and more importantly, they are accepting that UAP sightings pose a potential threat to flight safety. This seems to imply a real phenomenon that is more than just weather-related problems or misidentification. It also seems to suggest that there are data to validate the reality of the objects, though that certainly does not take us directly to the extraterrestrial. There are theories about drones and surveillance by foreign nations using craft that might seem to be unconventional given some of the new designs that have been suggested. In other words, these would be real craft that have a terrestrial origin.

In one of the few UAP reports they did examine; they provided an explanation for the “Go Fast” Navy cockpit video. In a one-page analysis of the sighting, they wrote:

We can use other information from the display to place some limits on the true velocity of the object. This analysis is summarized… which depicts an overhead view of the encounter during a 22-second interval. The jet was banking left at about 15 [degrees] during this time, which corresponds to the approximate turning radius of 16 kilometers. We know the range and bearing of the object at the start (t=0s) and the end (t=22s) times Using the calculated true air speed (TAS) and a bit more trigonometry, we find the object moved about 390 meters during this 22-second interval, which corresponds to an average speed of 40 mph. This is typical of wind speed at 13,000 feet.

This is the CIA sponsored Robertson Panel suggestion. Use a mysterious sighting, provide information about it and then provide a plausible explanation for it. If, of course, national security rears its ugly head, well, nothing is said. I doubt that anyone on the NASA panel is aware of the history or what recommendations the Robertson Panel made in 1953. Additional information about the Robertson Panel can be found here:

http://kevinrandle.blogspot.com/2021/06/the-uap-report-and-historical.html

http://kevinrandle.blogspot.com/2021/07/coast-to-coast-operation-mockingbird.html

There were only three sighting reports and two of them were listed as solved. The other, a silver sphere speeding across the landscape is too small to have carried any sort of flight crew and is probably some sort of terrestrial object. They have been unable to identify it, but again, that doesn’t move us directly to the extraterrestrial.

THE FINAL ANALYSIS

There is nothing new in this report. It is just more of the same. A discussion on how to investigate the UAP sightings, how NASA will be working with other government agencies to gather data, and even some commentary on the mean Tweets that have been sent to some of the panel members. They have been advised that their careers are in jeopardy because of their association with this phenomenon. There seems to be pushback by some members of the scientific community which is, of course, irrelevant.

This is something that I have never understood. Take the alien component out of the investigation, meaning simply that they are looking at the data provided, and there are things that might be of scientific interest. Many of the advances in science have been made by accident. To reject data because it might lead to an extraterrestrial source has always seemed to be narrow minded to me. Of course, that might be why there is an emphasis on aviation safety and the suggestion of a national security component in this latest report. It masks the fact that they are looking at sightings which, in another and earlier era would have been called flying saucers. And that might explain why they insist on calling them UAP. That hides some of the stigma of chasing flying saucers, though to be honest, that’s one of the things they are doing.

But there is nothing here that we haven’t heard before. After recent years of reports, hearings, meetings and press conferences, there is a hint that some investigation has been completed, but in many cases the various organizations are still attempting to figure out how to go about the investigation and how to gather the necessary data. They seem to be obvious to what has gone on in the past, they are unaware of some of the great cases that have been overshadowed by government agencies that are simply denying what they don’t wish to acknowledge and haven’t looked at any of the MADAR data that has been collected.

Or, I suppose, we could suggest that we have created another massive, governmental entity that will solved nothing, do nothing and eventually be seen as another colossal waste of taxpayer money. As the interest wanes, the importance of this latest investigation will change from a scientific enquiry to a public relations campaign to convince us all that there is nothing to see here. That is what has happened before, several times. They seem to believe that the interest will fade but forget that it always returns.

Thursday, September 14, 2023

Jaime Maussan and those Small Creatures

There has been news from Mexico about the recovery of small, intelligent creatures that might not be of human origin. The news was announced by Jaime Maussan, who has been involved in UFO research for decades, and who has presented what appeared to be non-human beings in the past.

According to the testimony, given under oath to the Mexican Congress on September 12, the beings were recovered from Cusco, Peru, and that thirty percent of their genetic composition is unknown. Carbon dating by the Autonomous University of Mexico (a reputable organization with three alumni having earned Nobel Prizes), suggest the corpses were more than a thousand years old. They appeared to have stereoscopic vision, three-fingered hands and no teeth.

Maussan said that the specimens are not part of our terrestrial evolution. He also noted that they had not been associated with any UFO wreckage. He said, “Whether they are aliens or not, we don’t know, but they were intelligent and the lived with us. They should rewrite history.”

This is not the first time that it was announced that evidence of alien visitation or strange humanoid creatures captured media attention. In the mid-1990s, it was announced that several small, 16 mm film canisters had been found containing what appeared to be an autopsy of an alien being recovered from the Roswell crash. In the end, the film was an admitted hoax. Those who created the film provided photographs showing the creation of the aliens. I have covered all this on this blog and you can read it here:

http://kevinrandle.blogspot.com/2010/05/alien-autopsy-is-hoax.html

http://kevinrandle.blogspot.com/2016/04/the-end-of-alien-autopsy.html

http://kevinrandle.blogspot.com/2006/04/end-of-alien-autopsy.html

http://kevinrandle.blogspot.com/2016/05/alien-autopsy-and-h-beam.html

http://kevinrandle.blogspot.com/2018/03/why-im-beginning-to-dislike-ufology.html

In 2013, Dr. Steven Greer announced a documentary about a tiny creature that had been found in the Atacama Desert in Chile. The humanoid being was only about six inches tall. Genetic research identified nearly all the DNA as human but suggested that some of the DNA could not be identified. The argument was that the unidentified DNA suggested an other worldly connection.

The ultimate conclusion was that there was nothing alien found. You can read a scientific analysis here:

https://genome.cshlp.org/content/28/5/607

The paper is from the National Library of Medicine and if you don’t wish to read the whole paper, which is short, I note they concluded:

This was a girl with many DNA mutations, not anything more exotic. Further functional studies of these alterations may lead to a clearer understanding of the genes that regulate bone development and might help the world diagnose and treat other children with genetic diseases driving bone growth abnormalities.

This probably is the reason why there is nothing much heard about this discovery after the paper was published. I did wonder, and I don’t believe anyone has ever addressed this. Would an alien species, evolved on a planet outside the Solar System reproduce using DNA?

Just a few years ago, Jaime Maussan was heavily involved in what I call the Not Roswell Slides fiasco. Just like with the Alien Autopsy, this received worldwide interest that culminated in a spectacular presentation in Mexico City. Within seventy-two hours, it was learned that the alleged alien body was that of an unfortunate child whose mummified remains had been discovered in the late nineteenth century. The photographs of the body were taken in a museum in 1947. You can find many postings about that on this blog and a few of the more relevant ones are here:

http://kevinrandle.blogspot.com/2019/08/x-zone-broadcast-network-tom-carey.html

This is an interview with Tom Carey and in the article are the links to more of the postings.

The point is that we have gone through this sort of thing for the last thirty years or so. Each of these presentations and announcements have ended the same way. The evidence, when examined dispassionately and by disinterested third parties, has failed to withstand the scrutiny. One was an admitted hoax, one was exposed as a hoax by the available evidence and one was, to be kind, a misinterpretation of the anthropological and archaeological evidence.

I will note that in each of the cases, there were various experts consulted who suggested that hoax was impossible, that the evidence suggested an alien visitation, and many times when confronted with new data, refused to reverse course.

I also noted that the wording by the experts in this case was very careful. They were not claiming these were aliens but the tests suggested the bodies were a thousand years old. Even Jaime Maussan was careful, saying that they did not know if the bodies were alien or some sort of alternative sentient life that evolved on Earth.

If these bodies represented another sentient race from Earth, I must wonder why there isn’t some sort of record of them somewhere. If the bodies are only about a thousand years old, then I would expect that we would have found other evidence of them. It is not as if they were a million years old or ten million years old. These are relatively recent in the history of the planet.

Like many others, I’m skeptical. Some of the reasons are laid out here, but another is that we have yet to see a wide range of scientific investigation. There is so much more that must be collected before we conclude hoax, misidentification or alien visitation. I will be interested in that scientific investigation when conducted and what conclusions are reached then. Until then, well, I’m skeptical but I don’t reject any of the hypotheses at the moment. We need more evidence. 

Friday, September 08, 2023

Roswell's International UFO Museum and Research Center

 

I was recently in Roswell for an update on some of the investigations from a few years ago. It was an opportunity to gather additional information, check out some sites, and verify or answer a couple of questions. I hadn’t been to Roswell in several years, so, of course, I made a trip to the International UFO Museum and Research Center. The changes there have been extraordinary.

The International UFO Museum and Research Center.


The original concept was a creation of several people including Walter Haut, Glenn Dennis and Max Littell, with input from Don Schmitt and me. It began with few exhibits and gradually grew into a somewhat impressive place, complete with some science fiction aspects, a major library of UFO books and other materials. It has also become something of a commercial enterprise, which, of course, it not necessarily a bad thing. That aspect has brought in donations that have allowed for the expansion and improvement of the Museum.

From the left, Don Schmitt, Walter Haut and Max Littell.


The displays are of professional, or maybe I should say, museum quality. A great deal of effort went into the creation of those displays. Some of them are scientifically oriented and others find their home in science fiction. There is a huge statue of Gort, the robot from the original The Day the Earth Stood Still. In contrast, there is a display of a dead alien in a hospital or morgue setting from the ShowTime original movie Roswell. It could be argued that the display is based on eyewitness testimony.

Gort from The Day the Earth Stood Still.



The alien from the movie Roswell.

There is an enclosed “spaceship bridge” that is very impressive that takes you on a visit to the cosmos but there is also a UFO landing scene that isn’t quite as impressive. It has been there for years and it does, periodically, emit smoke and loud noise.

One section covers some of the more notable UFO cases including abductions. I wish they had done more with the Hickson-Parker abduction. As I noted in an earlier post, Calvin Parker had died recently.

If I have one complaint, it is simply a small display about MJ-12. Most of the UFO community accepts the theory that the MJ-12 documents are a hoax. One of the first recipients of those documents, including the Eisenhower Briefing Document and the Truman Memo, had said that he had been thinking about creating some documents to further his research. That comment, among other evidence, suggests that MJ-12 is a hoax. I hope the Museum puts up a qualification about the documents suggesting their dubious nature.

Just one of the many new displays in the Museum.


And, of course, there is a gift shop filled with almost everything Roswell you can think of. And again, when was the last time you went to a museum that didn’t have some sort of gift shop. This is not a bad thing.

All in all, the Museum is now quite impressive. While it is not as large as the Smithsonian or some of the Museums of Natural History around the country, it is as professional done as those. I don’t suppose I have to say this, but if you find yourself in Roswell, a trip the museum is worth your time.

Sunday, September 03, 2023

Why Aren't There High Quality UFO Pictures Today?

A complaint that is often made is that nearly everyone is carrying a high-quality camera in their pockets, but we have no good pictures of UFOs. Ignoring the fact that there have been many high-quality photographs and even some perplexing film, there might be another answer for this criticism. It might be that there is a mechanism that blocks the digital cameras from taking those high-quality photographs of the UFO, while the rest of the photo is high quality.

UFOs over Colorado.


The first point is that we have evidence that some UFOs emit some sort of electromagnetic field that does interfere with the operation of systems that rely on electricity. We all know about the electromagnet pulse (EMP) that is the result of an atomic explosion and that can destroy electronic devices. In Levelland, Texas, on November 2, 1957, dozens of people reported to Sheriff Weir Clem that their cars were stalled by the close approach of a UFO.

Let’s take a look at the Condon Committee’s “scientific” search for evidence. The Levelland case was virtually ignored by them because they could think of no way in which an engine that had been stalled by an electromagnetic field could spontaneously restart when that field was removed. I made an analysis of more than five hundred vehicle interference cases that revealed that in the majority of them, the driver took some action to restart their cars. Very few suggested the car restarted on its own which negates the Condon Committee criticism.

In Levelland, one driver insisted that his car did spontaneously restart, but the other witnesses who were interviewed suggested that the car could be started normally when the UFO was gone. They started the car, but the Condon scientists just ignored that evidence by making a claim that was simply not true. Levelland was a case in which the UFO interacted with the environment, there are reports of landing traces, and there were, according to the sheriff, “hundreds of telephone calls” about the UFO.

The point here is that we have evidence that some UFOs generate a field that can alter the proper performance of a vehicle’s engine. The EM field also interferes the operation of the radio and there are many reports of a close approach of a UFO can dim street lights, knock radio and TV stations off the air, and cause other, reported effects, including responses from animals.

In just a single example of animal response, on April 5, 2018, the witness, in Deridder, Louisiana, reported, “My dogs began growling in the living room… and the cows in the pasture across the street were mooing loudly. I went to the large picture window in the living room facing west… I observed a huge round white light traveling slowly in my direction… For fifteen minutes, the light grew in intensity and pulsated.” When the light disappeared, both the dogs and the cows stopped reacting.

In a weird variation of some of the EM Effects, there are reports of car paint changing color after the close approach of a UFO. Otto Binder was one of the first to report that, after an approach by a UFO, the car’s paint changed from gray to purple with a strange patchwork of lines. There is no information about the date or location of the sighting and no witness is named. It could be overlooked as just a strange anomaly, but, over the years, there have been other such reports.

Robert Spearing, a dedicated UFO investigator with MUFON, who has been looking into cases of car paint changing color after being exposed to a high intensity magnetic field, has also noticed this. He asked the question: “Car paint has a number of possible oxides that theoretically can be victims of induced magnetic fields. But why are there not hundreds of cases of car paint changing color?”

According to his research, he found only two such cases. In November, 1953, while driving near Gjersjoen Bridge, Norway, three witnesses, identified as Trygve Jansen, Mrs. Buflot and a neighbor, watched an object as it rose from behind a hill. It oscillated over the lake for more than one minute, moved rapidly toward the witnesses and followed their car. The object passed over the vehicle and hovered ahead of them very low to the ground. Trygve stopped the automobile, and they watched the stationary object. During the sighting all three experienced mild electrical shocks until the object rose vertically.

When Jansen returned home, his wife ran from the house and asked if he had bought a new car. When he asked why she had thought so, she pointed that the car, that had been a dull beige was now a bright shiny green.

Spearing also reported that in 1978 there was a UFO sighting with EM Effects in Massachusetts. According to the witness, the Ford Mustang he was driving had the engine, water pump and the battery fried by the close approach of the UFO. The paint changed from white to grey and the car had to be junked rather than repaired.

The Condon Committee investigated a case that involved both the car’s paint and problems with the clock. This was Case No. 39 (page 380) in the Condon Committee final report. There is also a discussion of problems with the car’s clock as well.

Given that there is evidence that these EM Effects, there are some interesting sightings reported recently. On August 3, 2023, a witness in downtown section of Latrobe, Pennsylvania, spotted a series of lights that he first thought was an aircraft. As the light approached, he saw a solid dark triangular-shaped object.
He said, at the bottom was one white, steady light on each corner of the triangle, and in the center was a single steady red light. Along the sides were more white, steady lights. He said that the craft was about one hundred to two hundred feet long from point to point and was flying at about 1500 feet. The UFO made no noise.

For those who ask why we don’t have any good UFO footage because nearly everyone is carrying a good quality digital camera in a pocket, here’s part of the answer. The man took video of the UFO and saw the image on the phone screen. When he got home and tried to review the video, there was no image. He said that he didn’t know why it didn’t record. He also said that he watched the object for about three minutes.

 On July 29, Stan Gordon got a phone call from a witness who said that he had seen a massive, triangular-shaped object that emitted a bright greenish-orange glow. The UFO was hovering when he first saw it. The UFO then vanished only to reappear. There seemed to be an electric hum coming from it.

The witness took pictures with his cell phone. He could see the UFO on the phone, but the photographs showed a blurred image. He didn’t understand why that happened but it does suggest there might be some sort of electronic emission, invisible to the eye that affects the digital cameras.

From Boise, Idaho, comes a report on June 4, 2023. The witness spotted a bright object. He said it was tic-tac shaped, bright silver and made no noise. He tried to used his cell phone to take a picture but the image was little more than a white blob.

Las Vegas UFO.

The most exciting of these sorts of cases took place in August, 2013, as several Americans were in Canada hunting. It was about 9:40 p.m. when, as they were traveling back to the main lodging, they spotted some unusual lights flying low and slow approaching them. There was no sound and the lights were difficult to look at.  The witness pulled out his camera, a Sony Cybershot, but was unable to get it to stay on. He said that it would only stay on for one or two seconds and then would turn off.

The UFO approached to within four hundred feet and flying about 250 to 300 feet. It was as big as a house. There was what one witness called a plume of plasma and a cascade of sparks from the rear. The craft was made of shiny metal with a luminous finish and was in the shape of a dog bone or like a set of barbells.

Keeping with one of the bad traditions, one of the hunters fired at the UFO. He thought that the technology, whatever it was, would be impervious the lead slug from his rifle.

Now, one of the other witnesses picked up his Sony HD camera, and it stayed on. He hit record, but the screen was black though the UFO was still visible to the unaided eye. He picked up his cell phone but it was hot and the battery was dead. They all continued to try to record the incident, but found batteries were dead or something else was wrong. They video would not record, though they were able to record sound.

There is much more to the sighting. A full report was made in The MUFON Journal of March (No. 575) and concluded in April (No. 576) issue. The important point here is that the witnesses attempted to use multiple cameras including those in cell phones and failed to get a clear image.

In another example of this, on August 3, 2023, a witness said that his car was stalled by the close approach of a UFO. He picked up his cell phone but couldn’t get it to work.

Finally, there are a few other factors involved. In a sighting in Tremonton, California on July 16, 2023. The witness said that he saw a tic-tac shaped object. He watched it for about seven minutes and he did take some pictures and did get some video of the UFO. He did report, “Unfortunately, when it first descended, I forgot to push the record button.”

On July 24, 2023, the witness in La Port, Texas, reported seeing a large, silver disk-shaped object. The witness went to grab a cell phone, but the object was gone before a picture could be taken.

From Grand Junction, Colorado, on May 1, 2023, a man in his garage when a bright flash caught his attention. He saw what he called a classic flying saucer that had a slight dome on top. He said that he didn’t think of his cell phone at first. He turned to grab it and when he turned back the UFO was gone.

Here’s the real point. Remember, that some 95 to 97 percent of all UFO sightings have a prosaic explanation. They are strange clouds, sundogs, bizarre weather conditions, balloons, high flying aircraft and a multitude of other mundane objects. Many of the videos and photographs taken are of these things. Recently, dozens of pictures have been taken of SpaceX rocket launches and Starlink Satellites. They are clouding up the issue.

In studying hundreds of recent sightings, I see where the witnesses have attempted to photograph the UFOs, but their cameras fail. When the UFO is gone, the cameras work properly.

Or we see that the person has turned to find their camera, or they have gone to find their cell phones. When they return, the UFO is gone. The sighting didn’t last long enough for the camera to come into play.

Or, even stranger, the witness, carrying a camera in his or her pocket or purse or briefcase, until the UFO has disappeared has forgotten about the cell phone. The sighting was fleeting and before the since of wonder had disappeared, the UFO is no longer in sight.

Or, the object, which is well defined somehow produces an image that is little more than a blob of light. It could be that the camera detects some sort of radiation that obscures the object.

As I say, and as I noted here, we know that some UFOs create an electromagnetic field that interrupts the flow of electricity. All of this, I believe, explains, partially, the reason we don’t have more good pictures of UFOs. I would like to say that if the image is clear and distinct, then the picture is faked, but that is overstating the case.

I’ll leave it here. The evidence suggests that some UFOs interfere with the operation of the recording devices. This does not fully explain the problem but it does suggest a reason why we don’t have many good UFO photographs given the nature of society today. Maybe we just need to go back to good old fashion film and cameras that don’t require electricity to work. 

Saturday, September 02, 2023

Calvin Parker of Pascagoula Fame is Gone

A few days ago, Philip Mantle passed me the sad news that Calvin Parker had succumbed to cancer. He said the family asked for the news to be held for a few days so that they could make all the proper arrangements. This I did.

Calvin Parker


I will note here that I had the opportunity to speak with Calvin a few times and did interview him on my A Different Perspective radio show/podcast. I asked what I thought were tough questions, things that I had wondered about for years. He never shied away from those questions and answered them easily. He inspired me to write what I thought was a companion book to his books, and those of Philip Mantle and Irene Scott about the 1973 abduction.

During my first interview, he mentioned additional witnesses to the abduction and I thought these were people who had come forward in the last couple of years. He corrected me, saying that some were only recently identified, but there were witnesses to the abduction and the names of four of them were given to the Air Force the day after the abduction. This was corroborated in document that had the names of several Air Force officers on it who were involved with testing and interview on October 12, 1973.

Here's the point to that. I must wonder what the Air Force was doing investigating an abduction case in 1973, four years after Project Blue Book was closed and the Air Force claimed they no longer investigation UFO sightings.

I mention all this as sort of a preamble to Philip Mantle’s sad announcement today. Following is the information that he passed along to us:

 

GONE FISHING – CALVIN PARKER

 BY PHILIP MANTLE

 

It is with great sadness that I have to inform you that Calvin Parker passed away on August 24th at 8.15 am. He died peacefully at home surrounded by his wife Waynette and other loved ones. Calvin was diagnosed with terminal kidney cancer some time back so we knew his time was limited but it was still bad news when it arrived. A private memorial service was held at the Guardian Angels Funeral Home on September 2nd. At the request of Calvin’s family, I have not released anything in public until now.

For those who don’t know who Calvin Parker is, he was one of the two men involved in the 1973 alien abduction case on the Pascagoula River, Mississippi on the evening of October 11th, 1973. You can find the full information on these events at: https://de173.com/calvinparker/

Calvin and I had become close friends over these last five years and we talked regularly on skype. He was a charming, intelligent man with a great sense of humour. I’m not ashamed to admit that I cried when I was informed by his wife Waynette that he had died. Thankfully I spoke with him the week before and told him that I loved and respected him. He already knew that anyway. I also told him that he had more friends around the world than he could ever imagine. His personality, his story and his two books touched a great many people and also helped him get rid of some of the trauma that he had carried since that night in 1973.

When I began working with Calvin I agreed that I would help him cement his legacy. That legacy was to tell his story in full and help to document it for posterity so that future generations will have this information to study and maybe help understand what happened to him and Charles Hickson that night. Calvin was simply looking for answers, some of which he found, others that he didn’t.

I could continue to tell you more about Calvin Parker but I would instead suggest you listen to one of the many podcasts he did. Charles Hickson can also be located online telling his side of the story. Of course, it was their love of fishing that took them to the Pascagoula River that night in October 1973.

 Maybe old anglers don’t die, they just go fishing in a bigger river.

--

Philip Mantle
FLYING DISK PRESS

 

Philip also added a brief request for additional information about the case. He and Dr. Scott have been seeking additional information for years. He provided an address for that information.

MORE INFORMATION REQUEST 

Even though Calvin Parker is no longer with us the search for more information continues. I know there are people out there who have more information on this encounter case and I would like to ask them to release it now before it’s too late. Please do the right thing and let me have it. It can be sent to me in total confidence if required. Don’t hesitate, just send it now.

There may well also be other eyewitnesses to the UFO events in 1973. We have already interviewed a number of people, some in complete confidence at their request, but many others who have also allowed us to use their real names. If you are one of those witnesses please do not hesitate to contact me at the earliest opportunity and in complete confidence if required. Time is against us so please do not hesitate.

I can be contacted on facebook at:

https://www.facebook.com/philip.mantle.9

Email: philip.mantle@gmail.com

Telephone; +44 (0)771 088 3054

Address: Philip Mantle, 4 St Michaels Avenue, Pontefract, West Yorkshire, England, WF8 4QX.

 

For those interested, my book, referenced above is called 1973: A Time of UFO Sightings, Landings and Abductions.

And for those who would like to hear to my interviews with Calvin Parker, you can listen to them here:

http://kevinrandle.blogspot.com/2019/03/x-zone-broadcast-network-calvin-parker.html

http://kevinrandle.blogspot.com/2020/07/x-zone-broadcast-network-calvin-parker.html

Friday, September 01, 2023

The AARO Website

 

Just yesterday, the DoD put out a press release about the AARO office and the website that has been created. AARO, defined as the All-Domain Anomaly Resolution Office, has put up a website. While there is some criticism for it, I’ll note that it seems to be still under construction. There are some videos up and some information, which doesn’t bode all that well for UFO research. But following is the press release, as well as a link to the site.

 

RELEASE

IMMEDIATE RELEASE

The Department of Defense Launches the All-domain Anomaly Resolution Office Website

Aug. 31, 2023 |   

Today the department launched a website on the All-domain Anomaly Resolution Office to provide the public with information concerning AARO and its efforts to understand and resolve unidentified anomalous phenomena. 

This website will provide information, including photos and videos, on resolved UAP cases as they are declassified and approved for public release.  The website's other content includes reporting trends and a frequently asked questions section as well as links to official reports, transcripts, press releases, and other resources that the public may find useful, such as applicable statutes and aircraft, balloon and satellite tracking sites.  

This fall, consistent with Section 1673 of the National Defense Authorization Act for Fiscal Year 2023, AARO will launch a secure reporting tool on the website to enable current and former U.S. government employees, service members, or contractors with direct knowledge of U.S. government programs or activities to contact AARO directly to make a report.  The department is conducting its final reviews to ensure the reporting mechanism complies with the Privacy Act of 1974, the Whistleblower Protections Enhancement Act of 2012, the Federal Employee Antidiscrimination and Retaliation Act of 2002 (No FEAR Act), and the Paperwork Reduction Act of 1995.  In the interim, current U.S. service members, U.S. government employees, and civil aviators are encouraged to continue to use the existing reporting mechanisms available to them through their organizations.  A mechanism for members of the general public to make reports will be announced in coming months.

The department is committed to transparency with the American people on AARO's work on UAP.  This website will serve as a one-stop shop for all publicly available information related to AARO and UAP, and AARO will regularly update the website with its most recent activities and findings as new information is cleared for public release.

You can see AARO's new website at https://www.aaro.mil.

Thursday, August 24, 2023

Latest News on Congressional UFO Hearings

 

Things are not all that great in the world of UAPs, which I mention using the new acronym for UFOs here to distinguish it from the world of UFOs which is a separate entity. Just Wednesday night, at the first Republican debate, Chris Christy was asked about an encounter with alien creatures. His answer was poorly formed and does nothing to suggest that many attitudes have changed, even with the supposedly positive discussions held at some high government levels.

Some that was seen when Kirsten Gillibrand, in a speech in Glens Falls, mentioned UFOs. The crowd reaction floated somewhere around derision. There was laughter when she moved to the subject of UFOs. It might be that she referred to the Navy pilots and David Grush as some pilots and the second guy. Not sure why she didn’t name names here but the real point was the negative crowd reaction.

Although she seems to believe in AARO and that Sean Kirkpatrick is competent and capable, I have seen nothing to suggest that he has entered the arena as an unbiased source. In the various hearings and briefings, he has been a part of, he has provided very little in the way of investigative evidence. He seems more interested in the logistics of the investigation as opposed to the gathering and review of that evidence.

The worse part of this that she suggested that Congress might never get the truth about the Special Access Programs known as SAP. Although Grusch had said he knows the names of those involved in the creation of the UFO programs and that he has the names of firsthand witnesses, we still haven’t heard much about it and the little information we do have is somewhat disturbing. It does seem that the plan is to drag all this out until the public tires of it or a new administration can kill it.

Confirmation of this came earlier today when Chris Mellon said that he thought there was little prospect of further hearings about UFOs by the House Oversight Committee though there is still legislation that provides precedence for declassifying UFO information. That might be the one positive here.

However, Mike Turner of Ohio, who chairs the Permanent Select Committee on Intelligence has convinced James Comer who is the Chair of the House Oversight Committee that additional hearings could harm the reputation of the DoD and further hearings should be avoided. This seems to suggest there will be no more hearings on the topic, at least in the near future, and that would surely affect the disclosure of information.

Further, Turner disregards Grush’s testimony though there are members of the committee who take it seriously. I have worried about Grusch’s mention of the Italian UFO crash, which is apparently a hoax could undermine some of support that Grusch has had recently.

I wonder if they have had the classified briefings in which Grusch named names and provided the documentation. If so, that testimony wasn’t overly persuasive and there must have been some problems with the documents. If there were problems in those classified briefings, if they were actually held, that might explain some of the reluctance to support Grusch’s whistleblower claims.

I suppose that I should note that some of Turner’s campaign donors are large Defense and Aerospace organizations. This amounts to something over a hundred thousand dollars. That might have had some influence on his decisions concerning UFOs, though there are other donors who provided a great deal more money who are probably not interested in UFOs.

But there is some good news. Stan Gordon, who began investigating UFOs in the 1960s, and is the force behind the research into the Kecksburg UFO crash of 1965, hosts a website called Stan Gordon’s UFO Anomalies Zone. It covers a range of paranormal phenomena, though my interest is in the UFO sightings.

Stan Gordon


As an example, is a sighting reported on August 3 of this year from the downtown section of Latrobe, Pennsylvania. The witness, who was taking an early morning walk when he spotted a series of lights that he first thought was an aircraft. As the light approached, he saw a solid dark triangular-shaped object.
He said, at the bottom was one white, steady light on each corner of the triangle, and in the center was a single steady red light. Along the sides were more white, steady lights. He said that the craft was about one hundred to two hundred feet long from point to point and was flying at about 1500 feet. The UFO made no noise.

For those who ask why we don’t have any good UFO footage because nearly everyone is carrying a good quality digital camera in a pocket, here’s part of the answer. The man took video of the UFO and saw the image on the phone screen. When he got home and tried to review the video, there was no image. He said that he didn’t know why it didn’t record. He also said that he watched the object for about three minutes.

Stan also reported on what he called a surge of activity over the July 28 to 30th of this year. Some of the reports related to Bigfoot hunting in which I was uninterested. On July 29, Gordon got a phone call from a witness who said that he had seen a massive, triangular-shaped object that emitted a bright greenish-orange glow. The UFO was hovering when he first saw it. The UFO then vanished only to reappear. There seemed to be an electric hum coming from it.

Here's why this is interesting. The witness took pictures with his cell phone. He could see the UFO on the phone, but the photographs showed a blurred image. He didn’t understand why that happened but it does suggest there might be some sort of electronic emission, invisible to the eye that affects the digital cameras. Before you laugh, remember, there are hundreds of reports of UFOs stalling cars and affecting other electronic devices.

You can find Stan’s website here:

https://www.stangordon.info/wp/

Friday, August 04, 2023

Dr. Sean Kirkpatrick Responds to David Grusch Testimony

 

Dr. Sean Kirkpatrick, who heads up the AARO program seems to disagree with some of the statements made by David Grusch about a multi-decade program to collect and reverse engine UFOs. Kirkpatrick has said that in his official capacity to investigate UFOs, he had seen nothing to suggest that there is alien visitation but there are some sightings that are not easily explained. Grush is saying, that in his capacity as a whistleblower that he had heard reports of alien visitation, that he has talked with those who have direct, meaning first-hand knowledge of crash/retrievals, saying that the government not only knows more but that they have recovered alien spacecraft and the bodies of the flight crews.

Sean Kirkpatrick at the Senate Hearing.


If you ask me which of these two I believe, I’m going to say that I want to believe Grusch because his statements validate my research and investigation over the last five decades. But that is what I want to believe.

Grusch giving testimony at the Congressional Hearing.


Kirkpatrick, saying that he had seen no evidence of this crash retrieval program and knows of no such program, is probably telling the truth. I will note, however, that his not knowing of the program is not quite the same thing as saying there is no such program.

What can we deduce from all of this?

I look back on the history of UFO research and investigation by various components of the US Government and see they make these sorts of opposing statements. Those who are supposedly in the loop and those outside the loop often contradict each other. In 1948, the Navy and the Air Force launched an investigation into UFOs. The officers who prepared the document, “Air Intelligence Report No. 100-203-79,” which was dated December 10, 1948, noted that they did not have access to all areas of military secrecy. They wrote, in part:

THE ORIGIN of the devices is not ascertainable. There are two reasonable possibilities: (1) The objects are domestic devices, and if so, their identification or origin can be established by a survey of the launchings of airborne devices… (2) Objects are foreign, and if so, it would seem most logical to consider that they are from a Soviet Source…

SINCE the Air Force is responsible for control of the air in defense of the U.S., it is imperative that all other agencies cooperate in confirming or denying the possibility that these objects are of domestic origin. Otherwise, if it is firmly indicated that there is no domestic explanation, the objects are a threat and warrant more active efforts of identification and interception…

IT must be accepted that some type of flying objects have been observed, although their identification and origin are not discernible. In the interest of national defense it would be unwise to overlook the possibility that some of the objects are of foreign origin.

I thought this important because this is where we are today. Please note the language used here and the conclusions drawn. And please note that we are no closer to an answer today then we were way back then.

What we have are two rather credible people, and I say rather because there is still much, we don’t know, who are at opposite ends of the spectrum. One of them saying yes there are and the other saying no there are not.

Others have suggested, after reading Kirkpatrick’s letter that he, Kirkpatrick, was calling the witnesses, that is Grush, David Fravor and Ryan Graves, liars. I see nothing to suggest that Kirkpatrick was calling either of the Navy pilots liars and it seems he might be annoyed with Grasch, he wasn’t really calling him a liar either.

Kirkpatrick, expressing his displeasure with the Congressional hearings that feature those three had written:

I cannot let yesterday’s hearing pass without sharing how insulting it was to the officers of the Department of Defense and Intelligence Community who chose to join AARO, many with not unreasonable anxieties about career risks this would entail.

They are truth-seekers, as am I. But you certainly would not get that impression from yesterday’s hearing.

Well, that wasn’t my impression. True, Grusch hinted at some strong consequences from his blowing the whistle, but it might be said that those problems came from the possible exposure of classified material. It might be that his superiors were worried about the compromise of legally classified material, some of which might not have a thing to do with UFOs, or UAPs.

Yes, what Grusch said was spectacular, but it must also be remembered that he was talking about things he had been told and things he had heard, but almost nothing of a first-hand nature. He would reveal those in closed sessions.

The problem for me was his claim that there had been a crash of an alien craft in Italy in 1933. This has been researched by colleagues in Italy including Edordo Russo. who has provided evidence of a hoax. Certainly, nothing revealed about this case could adversely affect national security. Certainly, if Grusch was on the inside as he claims, he would not have been fooled by this hoax.

So, while the news media, and many in the UFO community, are talking about lies and infighting, I think it boils down to two separate entities with ties to intelligence and information about UFOs, disagreeing with the importance of that evidence and the reliability of the sources. As I have said before, if we don’t know the sources and the cases, we can’t draw intelligent conclusions about the veracity of the information. All we can say is that Grush seems to be credible and that Kirkpatrick is the man in charge of AARO. At the moment, they seem to be opposed to one another but there might become a time when they are in agreement.

All we have are some rather astonishing allegations by Grusch and some hints that many of the most recent sightings have mundane solutions according to Kirkpatrick. Currently, we just don’t know which path to follow to the end but all the speculation isn’t really helping.

The mainstream media, when they don’t have facts or information, resort to repeating themselves and speculating about what is happening. They don’t really know either and have no special inside knowledge but that hasn’t ever stopped them from throwing out whatever strange comment they can think of.

I will point out that all the calls for transparency have been ignored and until we can lift that shroud of silence, we really won’t have the answers we seek. As many have suggested, we need a little patience, but I fear the bloom will come off this rose, especially with all the election nonsense going on (and what I mean here is that the election is more than a year in the future and can’t we take a break from the campaigning), interest in solving the UFO puzzle might just be switched to the back burner until it is conveniently forgotten.

Wednesday, August 02, 2023

A Quick Investigation

 

A few days ago, I received a call about a UFO sighting over the Midland-Odessa area in Texas. The description was of something high in the sky and close to the moon, meaning only that it looked like it was close based on the position of the moon and the object. It was apparently seen over a wide area and there were pictures of it available.

Frankly, I thought this was going to be another SpaceX launch, given the description and the apparent huge area over which this UFO was seen. I did find a picture or two, and it looked similar to those pictures of the SpaceX launches I had seen in the past, though not as clear and not as spectacular as some.

One of the Texas pictures of the SpaceX launch


The problem was I didn’t have an exact date. I checked the SpaceX website and there was a launch in the right time frame, but without the exact date, I couldn’t be sure. Over the next couple of days, I made periodic searches for more information and more data. I learned that the UFO was seen as far north as El Reno, Oklahoma, and there was a picture that was taken in Austin, Texas. That picture also left something to be desired, but it did remind me of those other SpaceX pictures I have seen.

When I found the proper date, I learned that the pictures and the sightings were of a SpaceX launch on the date of the sighting. Given the widespread nature of the sightings, given the photographic evidence, and given a launch from Florida at the time of the sightings, I must conclude that this was a SpaceX launch.

I started this with a verbal description of a UFO sighting, a suggestion of multiple witnesses, and a possible photograph. All important elements. Although this was spread out over days, in total time, probably less than an hour or two, didn’t require very much of my time. It was something accomplished at home, with Internet access, and a desire to be sure. It was an interesting diversion that has ended as an IFO… Identified Flying Object.