I’m
going to have to stop looking at the Internet because there is always something
there that pisses me off. The latest was a video about five conspiracies that
can be destroyed by asking a single question. Naturally, I clicked on it
because I was sure that Roswell would show up. It was the fourth of five. I was
surprised by the question that supposedly unravels the Roswell conspiracy.
That
question was, “Why did the 509th Bomb Group issue the press release
saying that they had captured a flying saucer in the Roswell region?”
It
is fine question but one that I have answered several times. The answer is
predicated on the timing of the question, meaning that the press release was
issued on July 8, 1947, only two weeks after the phenomenon had exploded in the
newspapers. Kenneth Arnold’s sighting of nine strange craft flying in formation
was the cause of the interest and the inspiration for the term flying saucer.
In those days that followed, there were hundreds of reports of flying saucers.
There were almost as many explanations for what they were as there were
newspapers and military theories. The idea of an interplanetary craft was one
of those but that explanation was not at the top of the list.
Ed
Ruppelt, who took over as the chief of Project Grudge which evolved into
Project Blue Book said that the Pentagon was in a panic over the reports. There
was a certain hysteria about the flying saucers. It was because no one knew
what was going on. Army Air Forces fighters had intercepted UFOs, and the UFOs
had paced commercial aircraft, not to mention cars on the ground. Part of the
hysteria was fed by those inventing their tales of close encounters suggesting
an alien invasion. No one knew what was going on.
When
Jess Marcel, Sr. returned to the Roswell Army Air Field with a carload of
strange metallic debris, no one knew what it was. According to the officers I
interviewed who were there at the time and would have been in a position to
know what was going on, were aware of the hysteria. After all, World War II had
been over for less than two years, the Soviets were throwing up an Iron Curtain
in Eastern Europe that suggested that a new war was on the horizon and now
there were tales of strange craft flying around the US unimpeded.
The
debris recovered by Marcel suggested that the flying saucers might not be
hostile or threatening. Blanchard’s thoughts were to announce they had a flying
saucer, though it was only bits and pieces of one, but it was enough that they
could relieve some of that hysteria. His thoughts were to remove that one
aspect from the public consciousness. According to the officers I talked to,
including Walter Haut, Colonel Butch Blanchard felt an obligation to report what they had
found.
Randle on the Debris Field in the early 1990s.
![]() |
| Walter Haut, the man who wrote the press release at his home in Roswell. Photo by Kevin randle |
But
the real turning point came after the press release was, well, released. That
was when the rest of the craft was discovered much closer to Roswell than the
debris field 65 miles away near Corona. It was here that the bodies were
recovered. That changed the dynamic. That told those in charge, meaning the
civilian and military leadership in Washington that what was recovered was
something so extraordinary that they created the cover up to give them time to
determine just what was going on. Were the flying saucers hostile? Benign? What
would it mean to our civilization?
The
events in Roswell were isolated because Roswell was in the middle of the desert
and the military could control all the information coming out of the town. They
shifted the story to Fort Worth and Brigadier General Roger Ramey. He was able
to put out the fire with the display of a weather balloon and a rawin target.
The tale died at that point and the press moved onto other stories.
But
the answer to the question about the press release is simple. When Blanchard
ordered the press release, all they had was the strange metallic debris, which
was just strange metallic debris. He thought to end some of the hysteria by
telling the public that they had found a flying saucer. It was nothing to worry
about. Blanchard, as the commanding officer at the Roswell Army Air Field, had
the authority to provide the press with information that he believed was
important. He had not seen the true value of the find until the craft and
bodies were located but believed it was his duty to suggest that they had the
situation under control. They had a flying saucer and it was nothing to worry
about.
The
trouble was, he issued the press release prematurely. Had he waited twenty-four
hours, it is unlikely we would have ever heard about the crash. It was a
tactical mistake but not a strategic one. The situation was altered within
three hours of the press release hitting the national wires. But the point here
is that I know why he issued the press release based on my discussions with
some of the senior officers on the base in 1947. Forty-five years after the
event, they provided an answer, but the skeptical community is now hung up on
Project Mogul, just one more evidence of how important the find was.
Now,
can we put that question into a footnote where it belongs and get onto the more
important aspects of the case?


5 comments:
Could Blanchard assume, and expect the public to believe, he had the situation under control on the basis of a single recovered "saucer"? Many had been seen and the press release was confirmation they were real. Ramey's cover story indicates he didn't agree with the reasoning attributed to Blanchard here.
The main argument here is that Blanchard was only aware of the debris field and completely unaware of a much more sensitive craft/body site at the time PIO Haut was delivering Blanchard's press release to local media around noon on July 8, 1947. This contradicts a large body of witness testimony (e.g. Schmitt/Carey, "Witness to Roswell") and other circumstantial evidence that the craft/body site had been found the previous day while Marcel/Cavitt were examining the debris field.
A secondary argument is that even though Marcel reported and came back with debris which he thought "not of this earth" because of its highly anomalous physical properties, Blanchard would put out a press release anyway. Is this plausible? What if it was a highly secret project of ours? What if it was Russian in origin? At the very least, I think Blanchard would have informed higher command first (as strongly suggested, e.g., by Dubose's testimony, e.g., about an initial secret debris shipment to Washington and Wright Field via Fort Worth while Ramey was away). He would have required the OK from higher command first before putting out any sort of statement. Had he gone rogue, I would imagine severe career consequences, which didn't happen.
It could also be argued that the public wasn't THAT jittery from the flying saucer reports, making Blanchard think that he needed to put out a "nothing to worry about here" story to prevent mass panic among the locals. From my review of hundreds of newspapers from that period, there was some concern about the saucers in certain quarters, including limited speculation about ET origins and what that might imply, but nowhere rising to the level of national hysteria. (www.roswellproof.com/eth-in-1947.html)
However, against this, there is the fact that just before Roswell base put out their press release, the AAF Pentagon press office put out their own PR stating that the Air Force had determined the flying saucers were not Russian, a secret project of our own, or "space ships". (www.roswellproof.com/flying-saucers-not-spaceships.html) Then followed the Roswell PR that they had recovered one. Then followed the third PR from Gen. Ramey with photos that it was just a weather balloon. Was this all just to calm down a frightened public? In part, maybe yes, but it also strikes me as a sophisticated disinformation campaign designed to ridicule the subject, cover up what had really happened at Roswell, and kill public interest in the flying saucers.
All of this would require a very long discussion of the evidence. I don't think I have it in me right now. Personally I haven't seen a definitive theory of why Blanchard put out the captured flying disc press release, though I currently lean strongly into a disinfo campaign designed by counterintelligence.
David/Kevin -- As best I can recall, while I was researching and writing my play THE ROSWELL TRIAL: A Courtroom Drama before its 2020 publication, at first I believed the press release was a mistake on the part of Blanchard -- simple as that. But on reflection, as noted above, of the "large body of witness testimony ... and other circumstantial evidence that the craft/body site had been found the previous day while Marcel/Cavitt were examining the debris field," I came to believe that the press release was intended to divert the attention of the public away from the more important impact site north of Roswell and toward the less important Foster Ranch debris field to the west. In other words, it was a form of disinformation.
However, neither Carey & Schmitt in their Roswell: The Chronological Pictorial(2020) nor Kevin (whose insight I respect with great esteem) agree with this assessment. So I have backed away from this as well.
The important point though must not be lost. The Roswell Crash of 1947 is of immeasurable significance in the annals of UFO study.
John Steiger, stick to your guns. :) Not surprisingly, you won't find that view in any book I know of, except a very obscure one, mentioned before.
What the Ramey memo may say about the press release:
Although exact wording is not unanimous, there is a good consensus among multiple serious readers of the Ramey memo that the base press release is referenced in the middle of the second paragraph (Line 6) in the phrase "....MEANING OF STORY" (although I think it best reads "....RELEASE OF STORY". The word before is variously interpreted as MISSTATE (me), MISTAKEN, MISTATED [sic], or NEWSPAPER. The phrase before I have long read as "...CIC/TEAM SAID THIS MISSTATE RELEASE OF STORY".
The important part here in my interpretation that it was a "CIC/TEAM" that was responsible for the base release, not Blanchard, the "RELEASE" word modifier "MISSTATE" suggesting a misinformation purpose. This also goes along with a little testimony (such as Sgt. Robert Smith--see Smith affidavit: roswellproof.com/smith.html or Earl Zimmerman: roswellproof.com/zimmerman.html ) of unknown CIC people at the base. In other words, Blanchard was no longer running the show at Roswell; counterintelligence was.
The last half of the second paragraph is dealing with how the situation was being handled publicly. First the base press release, followed by the "NEXT PR (Press Release) OF WEATHER BALLOONS" put out by Gen. Ramey, finally a recommendation by the CIC team to add radar target balloon demonstrations to firm up the weather balloon explanation in the public's mind. Historically, there was a slew of such demonstrations in the next few days, including at Alamogordo AAF and Fort Worth AAF. See details at roswellproof.com/militarydebunk.html
Post a Comment